Nerdy leaked passwords:
Treebeard - “This password has been seen 1,207 times before in data breaches!”
NedStark - 20 times
CerseiLannister - 30 times
youknownothingjonsnow - 61 times
PicardIsSexy - 0 times (!The_Picard_Maneuver@piefed.world you’re safe. ;)
edit:
Gandalf1 - 53,478
Gandalfthewhite - 51
sexygandalf - 6
NSFW leaked passwords:
spoiler
bigdick - 178,712 (!?!)
bigpussy - 9,226
longpussy - 26
longdick - 10,762
wetpussy - 61,575
wetdick - 579
twat - 6,588
dickhead - 201,942
Blueballs69 - 520
Weird leaked passwords:
BillClinton - 378
DonaldTrump123 - 792
youwillneverguessmypassword - 390
redgreenblue - 2,040
123qweasdzxc - 1,010,515
poopstick - 6,845
((More to come later))



I’d argue it’s generally a very sane reaction to instinctively say no when some service you don’t know about wants your password.
The commentor you replied to obviously didn’t know about the pedigree of haveibeenpwned beforehand