edit: The extension bow allows you to see Lemmy comments on any website on the web! As long as there is a Lemmy thread with the same URL as the website one you’re on when you click the extension a popup will appear displaying Lemmy threads and comments which you can vote and reply to!
cross-posted from: https://merv.news/post/644180
A couple weeks ago I reached out to the dev that makes the Reddit Comments for Youtube extension and asked him to enable support for Lemmy. The developer was already rewriting the extension and decided to implement Lemmy support as well! Here’s the GitHub and FireFox links. It also available for Chrome iirc.
The comments appear after you select an instance in the extension’s menu on any youtube video that has been posted to any Lemmy instance with a full url without a timecode. Invidious links and Lemmy comments on invidious instances still aren’t supported but since its supported by the Reddit comments it should be possible if someone submits a PR.
You must log in or register to comment.
I rarely ever comment on YouTube but this is a nice addition.
embedding videos directly to lemmy via peertube would be the real deal. It fix the problem of hosting videos by the instance, Leemings get videos and peertube get users and viewers. It’s a win win.
That would be awsome. If it had a way to embed a piped yt vid that would also be pretty rad.
The biggest thing I’m looking forward to in the fediverse is integration like this, I’m not tech savvy enough to know if it’s viable but open source software that’s designed to communicate with other instances feels like a perfect place for things like this to develop.
Ikeeo seeing things on Peertube, Lemmy and Masterdon that would suit integration with eachother, particularly when it comes to showing the Lemmy comment system under other parts of the fediverse.
deleted by creator
I’m too old. I still live by the mantra “Never scroll down on a youtube video. There be trolls.”
Is this built into Freetube?
YouTube became weirdly positive and fake a while ago, I actually think the mega cesspit of YouTube comments hasn’t been reality for a few years now.
I can’t tell if that’s because the Gen Z online communication style is to celebrate everything, which is nice, or because there’s an algorithm in place somewhere to make the comments more marketable, which is lame.
The latter. Creators still complain about comments because they see all the negative ones. YT just does sentiment analysis on them all and hides anything critical.
I’m a millenial and I write exessively researched comments backed by papers on youtube whenever I see stupid BS takes. Even under shorts. Glad those get more traction.
Don’t think so, but hopefully it will!
It used to be the case that YouTube comments were one of the lowest forms of communication known to mankind. It isn’t anymore, not for several years now. There actually are sometimes some intelligent insights displayed prominently there. I suppose they probably changed their algorithm somehow.
facebook takes the cake now. just trying to talk about the fallout tv show is torture. so many people complain its woke for having a woman protagonist
Facebook is only really useful for really small niche communities where most posts don’t get more than a handful of comments.
Ha ha no. Go search for videos about space or Antarctica or JFK etc etc. The comments are full of schizos.
Removed by mod
(⌐■_■)
ʕ•ᴥ•ʔ
I’ve been saying for years that Invidious needs to support comments. Glad there’s finally a free world option.
I’m not keen on browser extensions though. Is there a manual way? Is it a matter of searching a particular Lemmy instance for the video ID?
It used to support reddit comments (maybe still does?). Adding a lemmy backend seems like a natural progression.
Maybe they will support Lemmy comments after seeing the code for this extension. Here’s an open issue about it on the invidious github: https://github.com/iv-org/invidious/issues/4331
Aside from decompiling the extension and converting the Javascript to work with tempermonkey, I don’t think so.
Grayjay should have it too
Lemmy just keeps getting better and better.
deleted by creator
Very cool. How can I haz?
deleted by creator
Nice! This is a really cool little plugin. Definitely will be grabbing it in the morning.
This reminds me of Dissenter. It let people make comments about any webpage including news articles, YouTube videos, and individual social media posts.
Oh yeah I had forgotten the name for that extension. I remember loving the concept but the people who developed it were neo nazis iirc and all the comment were either extremely anti semitic or just angry stuff.
I hope someone makes a similar extension for Lemmy
That’s just genius like you can build an entire interactive ecosystem that way.
Is this can be a violation of any kind of term and condition?
!remindme 2 months
deleted by creator
You know what? Unknowingly I was planning to build a project like Disqus, and guess which techstack I was about to use, yeah Django.
What is that video xD Dutch oven wth kind of nickname is that for a battlebot man i’m dead
Thank you for sharing, and thanks to the dev for porting it to Lemmy ❤️ 💚
Greatly appreciate everyone’s efforts.
Didn’t gab do something like this a while back?
Yeah, it was called Dissenter.
I’ve put my lemmy instance url into the addon, but now it’s asking for my lemmy username and password. Is that mandatory? I have not seen any lemmy comments on youtube videos yet so possibly?
Yes, it does work without logging in I just tested it :)
Ty Nix.
So Google can now track me on Lemmy? No thx.
That’s literally impossible… How do you think Google would track you like that.
Granting permissions on crossposting allows tracking.
Are you under the impression that you’re commenting with your Google account or something? That’s not what’s happening at all.
Any comment on a Google platform reqs a login or identifier.
What’s being proposed is that the extension would modify the page to add a Lemmy frame for commenting. This frame is autonomous in the sense the user must provide his Lemmy login information for it to work, which is different from Google login information. Google is not even aware the page is being modified by an external comment section, and even if it could detect it, it wouldn’t be able to track individual users.
You’re not commenting on Google, but on Lemmy
There’s no connection to Google whatsoever. You are commenting on Lemmy with your Lemmy account. Google has no way to control or track you.
deleted by creator
“If you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear.”
When someone says their life is an open book, it could mean an open check book.
