Yeah, no, where I’m from it would be straight to jail for murder. But I’m far from convinced I wouldn’t make sure the threat is neutralized (if the opportunity arose as was the case described in the article) before I’d get my belongings back.
Yeah sure, from self defence in the spur of the moment maybe, but going back to your car and driving over someone multiple times doesn’t qualify as self defence
you don’t get to whine about the social contract after threatening bodily harm
if it was just petty theft in public id agree this would be an unwarrented escalation
but theft in home or car or on a person using a deadly weapon is you get whatever comes after
not that hard not to be a piece of shit
Maybe we as a society shouldn’t allow vigilante justice that takes killing as something they deem justified.
let me guess privileged and white?
first time this happens to you for real id be curious if your opinion is the same
police wont do shit, they’ll act offended you even wanted to give a statement
you wont get your money or items back
in fact this might happen again, i know a guy whose house was broken into 3 times before he held the guy at gunpoint and cops still let the ‘kid’ off because he was under 18, welcome to poverty
And lo and behold: investigation show there wasn’t even a knife, so she just straight up murdered someone and lied about it. Jailing her is justified.
wasn’t a knife or couldnt find it?
regardless i was arguing for the statement at hand, her lieing is an entire different argument now
you don’t get to whine about the social contract after threatening bodily harm […] but theft in home or car or on a person using a deadly weapon is you get whatever comes after
Well, luckily most legal systems don’t work that way. Once the initial thread of bodily harm is over you don’t get to take matters into your own hands. Self defence is only allowed against immediate threats. One you’re back in your car and locked the doors, there is no more threat. Most cars are pretty knife-proof. Just drive away and call the cops.
If you get to safety but then return with a bigger weapon, that’s full vigilante justice territory.
let me guess privileged and white?
Let me guess, American? You sure are a vindictive bunch.
And yeah, I know it’s rough over there and certain disenfranchised communities might not get much help from the police, that certainly is a problem. Does it justify vigilante justice? I’d say I’m open to hear it out in extreme cases, but that’s another topic. It does not apply to this situation.
It happened it Italy and it was a wealthy white women getting mugged by an illegal immigrant they already tried to deport. Pretty sure the police would have been all over that. Would it still be inconvenient for her? Sure. Does that justify her murdering him in return? No … not even if the knife existed.
regardless i was arguing for the statement at hand, her lieing is an entire different argument now
And this is really where the crux of the issues lies. People see a picture with some text on the internet and decide that a person deserved to die. That’s kind of fucked up. And with a bit of research it turns out the entire thing is bullshit.
There probably was no knife, I’d guess not even a threat. He probably just snatched her purse and ran off … and she murdered him over it with her car to get her stuff back and thought she could get away with it. That your fucking “white privilege” right there.
She foresaw hours on the phone with credit bureaus locking down her information, filing disputes, being investigated, and then decades of additional potential identity theft and said “No.”
Yeah, the death penalty for petty theft is the way to go for a peaceful society
Armed robbery isn’t petty theft.
Both of those things have specific definitions.
She made the knife up
https://www.perthnow.com.au/news/crime/italian-cinzia-dal-pino-sentenced-to-18-years-house-arrest-after-running-over-alleged-bag-snatcher-c-22421372
Fair
If you threaten someones life over pocket money you better be prepared to die yourself.
Turns out there wasn’t even a knife. So they didn’t threaten their life. But she did murder someone over it.
Devils advocate, but being threatened with a knife doesn’t necessarily mean a knife was present.
Still not an excuse to kill someone after they were no longer a threat, though.
Wow, geeze.
From self defence maybe, but I’m pretty sure that driving over someone multiple times doesn’t qualify as self defence anymore
Yeah, no, where I’m from it would be straight to jail for murder. But I’m far from convinced I wouldn’t make sure the threat is neutralized (if the opportunity arose as was the case described in the article) before I’d get my belongings back.
Fuck around and find out. Threaten my life and it’s all fair game.
Yeah sure, from self defence in the spur of the moment maybe, but going back to your car and driving over someone multiple times doesn’t qualify as self defence
FAFO still applies; don’t try to rob random strangers, because you really have no idea how they might react.
Well, she FAFOd and can’t leave her house for the next 18 years now.
don’t break the social contract
i know a guy who got seriously stabbed over a robbery like this
fuck that dude deserved ehat he got from this lady
She made up the knife part. Know the facts before you judge.
? and
who am i judging, i dont even know the perps name nor care to
my argument was to the info as presented if thats a lie its not the same argument
Which would mean shooting that lady is all fair game since she also broke the social contract by straight up murdering someone over material property.
See how what comes around goes around?
Maybe we as a society shouldn’t allow vigilante justice that takes killing as something they deem justified.
And lo and behold: investigation show there wasn’t even a knife, so she just straight up murdered someone and lied about it. Jailing her is justified.
what kind of back asswards logic is this
you don’t get to whine about the social contract after threatening bodily harm
if it was just petty theft in public id agree this would be an unwarrented escalation
but theft in home or car or on a person using a deadly weapon is you get whatever comes after
not that hard not to be a piece of shit
let me guess privileged and white?
first time this happens to you for real id be curious if your opinion is the same
police wont do shit, they’ll act offended you even wanted to give a statement
you wont get your money or items back
in fact this might happen again, i know a guy whose house was broken into 3 times before he held the guy at gunpoint and cops still let the ‘kid’ off because he was under 18, welcome to poverty
wasn’t a knife or couldnt find it?
regardless i was arguing for the statement at hand, her lieing is an entire different argument now
Well, luckily most legal systems don’t work that way. Once the initial thread of bodily harm is over you don’t get to take matters into your own hands. Self defence is only allowed against immediate threats. One you’re back in your car and locked the doors, there is no more threat. Most cars are pretty knife-proof. Just drive away and call the cops.
If you get to safety but then return with a bigger weapon, that’s full vigilante justice territory.
Let me guess, American? You sure are a vindictive bunch.
And yeah, I know it’s rough over there and certain disenfranchised communities might not get much help from the police, that certainly is a problem. Does it justify vigilante justice? I’d say I’m open to hear it out in extreme cases, but that’s another topic. It does not apply to this situation.
It happened it Italy and it was a wealthy white women getting mugged by an illegal immigrant they already tried to deport. Pretty sure the police would have been all over that. Would it still be inconvenient for her? Sure. Does that justify her murdering him in return? No … not even if the knife existed.
And this is really where the crux of the issues lies. People see a picture with some text on the internet and decide that a person deserved to die. That’s kind of fucked up. And with a bit of research it turns out the entire thing is bullshit.
There probably was no knife, I’d guess not even a threat. He probably just snatched her purse and ran off … and she murdered him over it with her car to get her stuff back and thought she could get away with it. That your fucking “white privilege” right there.
lol there is a reason vigilante justice as a concept is near universal
anyone claiming otherwise is ignorantly privileged as made obvious by your further comments
rich people that never have to deal with the consequences of course think the legal system works
just lol, regardless of her lying this shit happens daily and knives are a europe thing so i hope you’re not trying to moral high ground from there
She foresaw hours on the phone with credit bureaus locking down her information, filing disputes, being investigated, and then decades of additional potential identity theft and said “No.”
So now she faces years of incarceration instead.
Maybe doing a few phone calls was not that bad.