Last Thursday, in the music humanities class I teach at Columbia University, two students were giving an in-class presentation on the composer John Cage. His most famous piece is “4’33”,” which directs us to listen in silence to surrounding noise for exactly that period of time.
I had to tell the students we could not listen to that piece that afternoon, because the surrounding noise would have been not birds or people walking by in the hallway, but infuriated chanting from protesters outside the building. Lately that noise has been almost continuous during the day and into the evening, including lusty chanting of “From the river to the sea.”
I did some easy googling and it’s likely that John Cage would have wanted students to listen that way: “The powers-that-be have become more and more repellent,” he said in 1966. "Look at us in Vietnam. It is indefensible.”
Back to McWhorter:
I thought about what would have happened if protesters were instead chanting anti-Black slogans, or even something like “D.E.I. has got to die,” to the same “Sound Off” tune that “From the river to the sea” has been adapted to. They would have lasted roughly five minutes before masses of students shouted them down and drove them off the campus. Chants like that would have been condemned as a grave rupture of civilized exchange, heralded as threatening resegregation and branded as a form of violence. I’d wager that most of the student protesters against the Gaza War would view them that way, in fact. Why do so many people think that weekslong campus protests against not just the war in Gaza but Israel’s very existence are nevertheless permissible?
And what if John McWhorter were not a professor of linguistics, but actually a professor of cannibalism? That’d be pretty fucked up. What if, instead of writing books about language, he wrote books about how to cook and eat babies?
Favorite part:
The other night I watched a dad coming from the protest with his little girl, giving a good hard few final snaps on the drum he was carrying, nodding at her in crisp salute, percussing his perspective into her little mind. This is not peaceful.
I thought about what would have happened if protesters were instead chanting anti-Black slogans, or even something like “D.E.I. has got to die,”
What if, instead of being against bad things, the students were against good things? Really makes u think
What if, instead, they chanted “I like lemon merengue pie”? Then that protest would be absolutely nonsensical. Really makes you think.
If you think John Cage would not want you to listen to 4’33" while there’s chanting and marching going on outside, you know absolutely nothing about John Cage. He would consider that one of the best renditions of 4’33" ever played.
deleted by creator
literally just going down a checklist of “things you have to generally know about to get a music degree” but never teaching it in a way that could be illuminating or useful.
deleted by creator
[lenin quote]
I thought about what would have happened if protesters were instead chanting anti-Black slogans
This is the only retort libs ever have to defend their position. “I know my position is reprehensible, but what if instead hypothetically my opponents were the ones doing something cartoonishly evil?”
What instead of calmly speaking to me you were screaming and punching me with fists?
Or even more accurate to the times we live in: what if it wasn’t just some tweet on the internet but something you shouted at me five inches from my face?
Swear to God the internet has broken so many brains
just the absolutely most fragile people, thinking drumming is oppressive psychological coercion:
I watched a dad coming from the protest with his little girl, giving a good hard few final snaps on the drum he was carrying, nodding at her in crisp salute, percussing his perspective into her little mind. This is not peaceful.
This is actually entirely peaceful?? This is a thing my husband did with our kid when he was very little, and he has a deep appreciation for rhythm (and human rights) to this day. He used to fall asleep to metal music, he fucking loves that shit.
Drumming is magically peaceful! What a fucking idiot of a fascist.
Wicked, evil, antisemitic display of violence. Disgusting that the father is encouraging his children to do this. Real protests involve singing kumbayah and giving flowers to soldiers and tweeting
Real protests involve singing kumbayah and giving
flowersPepsi to soldiers and tweeting
McWhorter is an ”anti-woke” dipshit who thinks anti-racism is as bad as racism.
deleted by creator
It’s actually so he can listen to show tunes.
I thought about what would have happened if protesters were instead chanting anti-Black slogans, or even something like “D.E.I. has got to die,” to the same “Sound Off” tune that “From the river to the sea” has been adapted to.
Oh fuck off please, what a fucking whiny baby
McWhorter is another one of these people like Neil Degrasse Tyson, Steven Pinker and Sabine Hossenfelder, who are exceedingly knowledgeable in their fields but seem to think that that automatically makes them smart in other fields where they’re not qualified to speak at all.
His podcast Lexicon Valley was one of the first podcasts I got hooked on years ago, and despite his weird obsession with obscure and annoying show tunes, it taught me so goddamn much about linguistics. His voice and cadence may be exactly what I think a bowtie would sound like if it could talk, but man could that guy make me rethink my conception of language.
I was disappointed when he handed the feed off to some other guys and just up and left, presumably to write “[controversial topic] is not what you think”-type essays for The Atlantic, or to be the conservative’s favorite based lib talking head.
It’s really fucking frustrating when a guy who shared so many insights that are still relevant to me as a language teacher decides to pivot and become a both-sideser turbo liberal who panders to whomever is willing to pay attention to and quote the smart linguistics professor man.
Sabine regularly shoves her entire foot in her mouth wrt physics by making huge, unjustified assertions and generally ignoring or completely misrepresenting any counter argument thrown her way. Anyone who was tangentially part of the physics community wasn’t the least bit surprised by her YouTube absurdities.
He is supposedly the author of the book “Woke Racism” which has very predictable Amazon reviews. He seems to come across as an educated black guy giving libs permission to be angry about anti racism having “gone too far”.
I don’t even know what to say about this lol. These fuckers are so out of touch
I understand this to a point. Pro-Palestinian rallies and events, of which there have been many here over the years, are not in and of themselves hostile to Jewish students, faculty and staff members. Disagreement will not always be a juice and cookies affair. However, the relentless assault of this current protest — daily, loud, louder, into the night and using ever-angrier rhetoric — is beyond what anyone should be expected to bear up under regardless of their whiteness, privilege or power.
“These protests are not anti-Semitic and I understand that protests will be provocative. But interrupting my music class is taking it too far and is akin to assault.”
I wonder if there are any other “relentless assaults” that might involve bombs and starvation that phrase might evoke
aaaand PRINT
40,000 dead
Why do so many people think that weekslong campus protests against not just the war in Europe but Nazi Germany’s very existence are nevertheless permissible?
All Atlantic contributors will go into the Atlantic.
the beating will continue until the genocide stops
I had to tell the students we could not listen to that piece that afternoon, because the surrounding noise would have been not birds or people walking by in the hallway, but infuriated chanting from protesters outside the building.
I can’t believe the pro-palestine camp would be as uncivil as shudder birds chirping. I’m sorry, but I have no choice but to become a Zionist.
