People can be excited about whatever they want whenever they want.
I’m excited about your comment
I’m excited for your cake day!
This is not unpopular, it’s just nonsense.
The basis of this opinion is that consoles are “illegitimate”, presumably because they don’t let your own run arbitrary code / binaries and exist in a walled garden.
And my point to you is that however you’ve defined and used “illegitimate”, is absolutely and by definition, meaningless to the question of whether or not people can now buy and play and enjoy GTA6.
Evidently in your world, GTA6 is coming out and ot can be played and enjoyed both “legitimately” and “illegitimately”, so your opinion here about people getting excited is just kind of nonsense.
Evidently in your world, GTA6 is coming out and ot can be played and enjoyed both “legitimately” and “illegitimately”, so your opinion here about people getting excited is just kind of nonsense.
It’s coming out illegitimately now and legitimately later, so people shouldn’t be excited until later.
Also, to be clear, it’s the acts of the platform manufacturer and game publisher that lack legitimacy, not the acts of the buyers. I’m not trying to blame victims here: people who buy it on PS5 or Xbox are making a mistake, but it isn’t their fault.
An opinion both popular and unpopular at once; Schrödinger’s Opinion.
To be fair, it’ll be a few weeks at most before it’s available for emulation. But yeah, fuck Rockstar’s blatant attempt to double-dip
I’m just saying it shouldn’t be released on PS5 and Xbox at all. Because PS5 and Xbox shouldn’t exist at all. The entire business model of selling
consumerowner-hostile, DRM’d, intentionally-sabotaged-to-be-less-than-general-purpose computers should be illegal.They’re convenient, accessible, and more affordable.
Most people that end up in the PC gaming space started on a console. PC gaming is just as hostile to consumers, it’s just piecemealed out, so your hostility comes in easier to digest packets rather than a few big ones.
Get over yourself.
They are convenient and accessible, but I think they’ve lost ground on affordable. The games tend to be more expensive, I believe they all have a subscription for online play, and their library is much smaller. The latter is an indirect cost, but a decent PC today can play games from like the last 40 years, plus a good way into the future. You don’t have to re-buy stuff, or keep the old hardware around indefinitely.
Plus it’s more general purpose useful to have a full computer, even if people use their phone for most things now.
Sure, get in to the weeds and you’re bound to find a few stickers.
Ask someone with no PC and no console right now which they feel like they can afford and the console will probably win. The barrier to entry is just lower. It’s meant to be, the consoles are sold as loss leaders to get people in to the garden this guy is whining about.
I’ll grant you the PC is a better choice over the long term, most people either can’t afford that or don’t care. Most people also aren’t playing 40 year old games, and if they want to, they can do that far cheaper than needing an entire PC to do so. I have a retropi but find my phone with a controller can emulate most of the old games I want to play more conveniently than the pi can.
If all someone wants to do is play the most current sports game and whatever the current military arcade sim is, console is probably the right choice for them.
They’re convenient, accessible, and more affordable.
Sure, in the same way that paying the local mob enforcer protection money is more convenient and affordable than letting him wreck your shop and break your kneecaps. But that doesn’t make what he’s doing morally okay or a valid business model.
PC gaming is just as hostile to consumers
This must be some Windows shit I’m too Linux to understand.
Sure, in the same way that paying the local mob enforcer protection money is more convenient and affordable than letting him wreck your shop and break your kneecaps. But that doesn’t make what he’s doing morally okay or a valid business model.
No, not even remotely.
I’m not trying to be offensive here, is English not your first language? Or is being obstinate and obtuse your goal here?
It’s one thing to take issue with how the console ecosystem works. It’s quite another to take it to this extreme.
You’re basically saying that Target is a criminal enterprise because the only way to buy Good and Gather products is to shop at target. Ignoring both A: the actual shitty things they do and B, that plenty of other non retailer specific stuff is available both there and elsewhere.
Sorry dude the more you elaborate on your argument the more idiotic it sounds.
You’re basically saying that Target is a criminal enterprise because the only way to buy Good and Gather products is to shop at target.
No, that’s a bad analogy in several ways:
-
Good and Gather products have substitute goods available from other sources, while copyrighted works of art do not (by definition, since that’s what copyright is for!).
-
Target may be the only place selling the products, but it’s not controlling how you use them after the fact or what else you are or aren’t allowed to do with the other things you’re using those products with.
In order to to make your analogy work, you’d have to really torture it: it would be as if Good and Gather were the only brand allowed to sell (for example) frozen lasagna, and to cook it you’d have to use only a Target-brand oven, and the Target-brand oven was designed to disallow you from cooking non-Good and Gather foods in it. So you’d have to buy the Target-brand oven and the Good and Gather-brand lasagna or go without lasagna at all, because circumventing that restriction (including even by trying to make your own lasagna from scratch) would be illegal for some reason.
-
Not about to shill for corporate slop or the gradual enshittification of consumer electronics in the name of profit, because I agree with the message even if I think “making them illegal” is a braindead response that puts the power to control an art form into the hands of the government, but I’m of the generation that remember when consoles were the cheap option for people to get access to games, and gave people who were less well off the ability to experience a cultural event.
To clarify my disdain about “making them illegal”; removing and preventing the monopoly microsoft, sony and nintendo have over the game industry would certainly help the public, but making a console illegal isn’t going to change anything but increase the number of people in prisons.
I think “making them illegal” is a braindead response that puts the power to control an art form into the hands of the government
How does prohibiting DRM put control into the hands of the government? That’s what “making them illegal” means: without the DRM and the manufacturer’s ability to control what’s allowed to run, consoles just become normal, valid, general-purpose computers and I’m certainly not suggesting outlawing those!
making a console illegal isn’t going to change anything but increase the number of people in prisons.
To be clear, I’m saying it should be illegal for Sony and Microsoft to design and sell them as DRM’d closed platforms, not that already-existing ones should be illegal for individuals to own.
There’s no reason to be excited for GTA VI today
Is that really unpopular? In my experience most of the world is apathetic towards, ignorant of, or hateful towards GTA/Rockstar.
Walled-garden consoles are illegitimate platforms and don’t count.
What now? There are lots of walked garden platforms, e.g. iOS, Mac, increasingly Android, Nintendo. Please elaborate on your use of “illegitimate” here.
Being a walled-garden makes the platform illegitimate, inherently and by definition. Only open platforms are valid.
Making a walled-garden platform should be a crime.
I mean I sort of agree with the gist of what you’re saying - privately owned walled gardens invite abuse of power - but using a tautology of “it’s illegitimate because it is” is not a compelling argument.
That’s not quite my argument. I’m not saying “it’s illegitimate because it’s illegitimate,” I’m saying “because it’s illegitimate a priori, it doesn’t even count as a real example of the thing it’s pretending to be.” It’s like saying that drug-dealing doesn’t count as a business model because it’s illegal (where the illegality is treated as a postulate, not a topic of debate).
Also, the point is to be emphatic, not strictly correct. I’m trying to treat it as absurd in order to make people reevaluate their basic assumptions.
This is batshit and I think everything you’re doing is high quality posting
Who the hell is putting “must not be a walled garden” under the definition of “platform”
Me.
Richard Stallman-ass unpopular opinion, bravo



