It is because you are trying to justify the results after the fact rather than just letting the methodology speak for itself. Similar to flat earth and antiavax. Good for you if you turned out “all right”, but a right answer with bad input/logic is still flimsy. Scientific analog is Maxwell discovering the theoretical speed of light. Its as fast as light estimates so it must be. He’s right but other things could travel at light speed (like gravitational waves).

First of all, I want to make clear that I strongly suspect that this is not a genuine post, and has been posted on bad faith.

But to answer the question, the truth is that it’s impossible to know. You’re comparing a known outcome to an imaginary hypothetical one.

The real question to ask is, even if it was the case, do the ends justify the means?

Is it ever ok for an adult to physically attack a child in their care over, let’s face it, trivial matters?

I am curious how old you are now to hold that perspective. I used to believe I deserved to be abused as well. I was an awfully misbehaved kid and my mom was constantly fighting me, like fist-fighting me, because I would fight back. At no point in my life was there a time where I was just getting beat without throwing punches back its just how my brain worked. I used to think because I was like that, that I deserved it because good kids don’t fight back, they take their beatings and suck it up.

Then when I hit about 30-ish it dawned on me that I was a fucking child, a literal adolecent that didn’t know the mistakes I made would end with me getting punched in the mouth. The only thing valuable I got out of those interactions was learning how to fight.

However, the anger management and probation programs I was in between 12-16 did actually provide value to my life and taught me how to not be a psychopath like my mother. Though admittedly, it took a while for all those classes and workshops to really sink in. I now have the tools I need to understand my own emotions and when I need to walk away from a situation that is upsetting me, and I now understand that my actions have consequences and I don’t get to take them back just because I feel bad after the fact. This took years for me to figure out, and it should have been something I knew from childhood. I was too concerned with feeling like I was a bad kid just for being born not knowing how to do everything perfectly the first time.

People choose to attend universities like VMI for a reason