Most of the posts that are frequently featured in the homepage are about social problems or styles of life common to that country (or most first world countries), and even limit to only United-Statesian media discussion. They do not appeal to someone like me, who has different thoughts, different people, different problems. It’s hard to find something relatable in (most) non-local communities, because it’s just about this style of culture. It doesn’t helps with the poor website discorverability, making me limited to these same repetitive and unfunny posts.
I’m not following the proportion point, but about non-US on reddit, r/france has 2.1 M readers and r/de has 2.7 M readers. They are very active, it completely dwarves anything on Lemmy. Any national subject is going to be discussed there. I am not using those by activism, but I can’t blame the average person to prefer those vastly more active places.
Look at the daily posts on !melbourne@aussie.zone. They have several hundreds of comments every day, because the mods of /r/Melbourne supported the migration to Lemmy.
!ich_iel@feddit.org is kind of similar in that space, they had an official post to move to feddit a year ago: https://old.reddit.com/r/ich_iel/comments/14d65o7/öffentliche_dienstmeldung_änderung_der/
Meanwhile the mods of /r/France just removed every post mentioning Jlai.lu as it was “a social network”.
Shaking my head.
@oce
I’m not sure if they really have 2.1M readers on Reddit. I don’t trust those numbers due to bots, inative accounts…
And if Lemmy was really connected to the fediverse we wouldn’t have 1K users but lot more.
Even if we can’t trust those numbers, you can just check their frontages and see the number of posts and comments per day, it’s much more active.
How could it be more connected?
@oce
Well mastodon/iceshrimp’s users can’t see you. I can only see you there because i met you in jlai.lu first and added your account to my iceshrimp one. So right now, they can only see your jlai.lu account through me.
Outside my iceshrimp account or lemmyverse, you doesn’t exist in the fediverse.
ActivityPub, as i read should work that way : whatever the software is, we should access any content and interact with.
So, Lemmy is somewhat limited. Small support of hashtag, and we can’t follow people, nor react to their post. If ActivityPub worked well, those number as 1M would be irevalent as we should count the whole french fediverse community.
Same for Mastodon that doesn’t support forum style format.
I hope my explanation was clear. It’s still a wip project and i hope those barriers will be lowered and see software merging in some way. :)
I guess there are issues with the post formats, micro blog and forum styles are quite different, and there’s probably a cultural friction between people who like community based pseudonymous forums and strongly personified social media.
Let’s hope we can one day have a common share place for information with UIs adapted to every tastes.
@oce
That’s what i hope they will achieve one day. Both are good. And if they don’t see the forum structure they won’t notice. :)