Isaac (ieh)

  • 0 Posts
  • 51 Comments
Joined 3 months ago
cake
Cake day: July 3rd, 2026

help-circle







  • I’m glad to see this here.

    I think in the same way that the reddit community “Explain Like I’m Five” doesn’t require explanations to be geared towards actual five-year-olds, I think DadJokes are best described (and most commonly) silly puns. Jokes that tend to elicit a groan along with laughter.

    I don’t think gearing them towards children is necessary at all, and so I would remove the concern about sex completely.

    I’m an adult. I’ve never had kids. I enjoy dad jokes. It’s not about being an actual father, either, come to that.



  • From what i’ve seen from the modlog, I would expect a joke that revolved around dad referencing sex with mom (or their sexuality at all) would also get removed.

    Note that I don’t personally agree with the rule, it’s just a rule I don’t see as problematic, nor being enforced unfairly.

    Why don’t you have a problem with “bisexual” not being considered “gay”? Because you’ve decided that’s okay. And I don’t disagree necessarily, because for example we have LGBTQ+ which separates out the letters. But if you reduce that to a single word, it would probably be “gay”, meaning that bisexuality is also gay.

    I’m sure it would surprise some of the commentors calling me a bigot to learn that my wife is bisexual. Not that you can’t have members of some class being bigots. But I’d imagine it would sitll surprise them. Nor do most people who don’t actually give a shit about the conversation and who are just looking for a convenient target to hate care much either. Which is not you, which is why I gave you an actual reply.



  • I’ve taken a look at the moderator log, and they are pretty consistent about it.

    I can understand the concern - seeing this post caused me to go take a look.

    I’m open to my mind being changed, but it appears to me that they pretty consistently remove jokes with a sexual component, and often suggest c/unclejokes as an alternative place for posting them.

    At the moment, this looks to me to be a community rule that not everyone agrees with, but a reasonable rule to have and enforce. It certainly does not break the Lemmy.World TOS.

    The job of a moderator is to act as a janitor and facilitator. They remove spam, bigotry, and posts that don’t fit. And then hopefully help ensure the things that do fit are allowed - so the community then upvotes/downvotes on what they like or don’t like. But it is worth bearing in mind that moderators are all volunteers, and in addition to being a janitor and facilitator, they have often created the communities in question, and so should and do have a hand in how those communities operate. Ideally, it’s a balance between what the community wants and the vision the mod has for the community.

    I will also say that 1) everyone’s opinions on what crosses lines are different, and 2) after moderating in various places for 30 years of my life, I can say that a surprising amount of content requires subjective calls to be made, even with brilliantly objective rules. Context is surprisingly critical in many cases, for example, although in this instance, it’s more about where lines are drawn and what exactly is “sexual”.

    I personally don’t have any problems with this joke at all, and if I were the mod, I think I wouldn’t worry about what actual children might think of jokes - but that’s where this community is, and this removal seems reasonable to me based on that rule.



  • To speak frankly, I’d like to see a little more time and activity on your account. Here’s what I’d request from you: Start posting there some, and come back to me in one month. If I see you putting in that time, I’ll be a lot happier to hand moderator over to you. Right now, you’re a very new account, which is great - nothing bad I see - but I would just prefer to see you around a little more, then I’ll be happy to. :)






  • Oh, and a note on those two communites - someone (I don’t remember the username, so might even be you, but I think it’s someone else) has a pending request that is on my to-do list. I think it’s those two specifically. I just don’t have it handy in front of me - but if it is specifically those communities, probably working that tomorrow. :)

    edit: lol, I got curious. It is you. Probably transfer those tomorrow :)

    edit2: Actually, I see your activity in the first community I transferred which is plenty of assurance for me - went ahead and transferred. Thank you for volunteering! I’ll reply to the ticket now as well :)


  • Speaking only for communities on lemmy.world, since I’m an admin here and more recently am working a lot of these requests - any community that I do give to a new mod comes with the disclaimer that I contact the old mod(s) and if I’ve missed their activity, or they otherwise show up again - not much is permanent, including this. So at least here on lemmy.world, if I were to give away someone’s community and they popped up to protest, it’s all but certain I’d give it right back - although I might see if they’d be willing to bring on that other person as a mod to work with them, but as of yet this hasn’t happened, so we’ll cross that bridge when and if it does. :)

    Also, to you and everyone else who moderates: Thank you. You are indeed the first line of defense against spam and bigotry, and often are integral to making your communities grow. I’ve been a moderator (and am so) as well as an administrator here, reddit, and other places - and each has its own joys and difficulties, but mods are absolutely in the trenches. :)