• 0 Posts
  • 12 Comments
Joined 1 month ago
cake
Cake day: September 3rd, 2025

help-circle
  • One could argue that an adult in their 40s or 50s who chooses to date someone 21-23 or 22-24 deserves to die.

    Cool, that sounds fun, I’m always up for an argument. Before we start though, can you clarify the terms? Are you saying that:

    • Someone in their 40s who chooses to date someone 21-23 deserves to die; and
    • Someone in their 50s who chooses to date someone 22-24 deserves to die?

    What about a 49 year old who is dating a 24 year old whose birthday is the day after hers? What happens when she turns 50 and is dating a 24 year old for a day? Does she deserve to die? Or is that only if she starts dating a 24 year (+364 day) old during that time? What if they break up for that day, presumably that’s fine? What if she says “I’m breaking up with you, Kevin”, and he says “No, Lou-Anne, I won’t give up on us, I’m going to keep calling you, we are not over” and walks out, and so they’re technically dating for that day but it’s not her choice any more (“who chooses to date”).

    Also, what age are we using? Presumably we’re just going by the birthday, rather than going down to the time as well? Like someone who turned 40 today dating someone who turns 24 tomorrow. Obviously she deserves to die because she’s dating a 23 year old. But if she was born just before midnight and he was born just after, she might deserve to die, but two people whose age gap is even bigger (by a few hours) wouldn’t deserve to die. That doesn’t make sense, surely? So we need exact time of birth for some potential couples.

    Also, why the lower limits? I’m assuming you’re not advocating for paedophilia so let’s keep the age of consent the same. Why is it fine for someone in their 40s to date someone aged 18-20? If it’s not, why did you specify a lower limit?

    Is this a moral absolute (for those who could argue it)? Could a 40 year old be a good enough person to be allowed to date a 23 year old? Could a 39 year old be bad enough to not be allowed to date a 23 year old?











  • Yeah, “trivial” was too strong, but I do think that “punch them in the balls” is obviously impractical enough as not to count as a serious suggestion, particularly coming from a comedian.

    I’d be surprised if CPS took it any further and shocked if he actually got a conviction. But either way this just plays into the narrative of “woke snowflakes who can’t take criticism without crying to the police”, IMO. Just look at how much of a cause célèbre Lucy Connolly has become for the right, for what was objectively a much worse tweet.