This was a comment somewhere else, I wanted to make my own thread on it. One of these spoiler tags has a long rant.

I think Stranger Things S1 is pretty good. After S1, you can stop at any time you’re no longer feeling it and not be missing out on anything.

S2 spoilers

most people didn’t like S2 but I thought it was awesome, and agree there was a tiny drop of quality.

S3 spoilers

IMO S3 is where a serious quality drop starts. In addition to a general quality dip, the monster from S2 comes back but there is at least a twist so it’s not as bad of a rehash as Star Wars episode 7 felt like. Also the Soviets built a secret military lab under a mall, they should have hired some people to rework that part of the plot.

S4 spoilers

S4 has a lot of cool stuff going on it, but it’s all over the place in very silly ways. It has a lot of quality issues.

The lore was ambiguous about what the Mind Flayer (S2) was. The absolutely worst part is when the lore in S4 established that the Mind Flayer was not in fact, some cool mysterious eldritch god (you know, something strange), but actually just some 40 year old asshole LARPing as a spider using magic dust who also has super powers for literally no fucking reason at all. If you can ignore the lore downgrade, the season’s big bad (Vecna) is 50% okay and 50% wtf when did this become a Marvel movie?. The only thing they had to do to unfuck the lore was say “Vecna (some random asshole who has powers for no reason) and the Mind Flayer (eldritch shadow god thing) are working together (for literally any reason who cares)”. FFS who cares about some random asshole LARPing as a spider? That’s the fucking stupidest shit ever!!! First they’re like “As a child, Vecna was obsessed with spiders.” Then you’re like oh okay, that explains why he’s working with this shadow monster who definitely does not look like a spider but close enough for someone whose weirdly obsessed with spiders to be interested. Because if someone was that obsessed with actual spiders, they’d LARP as something that looks a lot more like an actual fucking spider.

Then everything is good to go, until they quickly pull a fast one on you, like they forgot at the last second that someone was going to ask “yeah that’s cool and all, BTW what does all this Vecna stuff have to do with S2/S3?” and then they do a quick lame exposition dump explaining that the upside down was just Vecna thinking about darkness and shit found some magic dust and used it to LARP as a spider (WHICH DOES NOT ACTUALLY LOOK LIKE A SPIDER HOLY RETCON BATMAN), and it’s extremely obvious this is a desperate attempt to retcon away the “sry kid, we were making it up as we go because netflix demanded with make more than one season” with “wow it was Vecna the whole time!!!”

Then everybody gaslights you that this was planned from the beginning despite originally the show was planned to be an anthology (and S1 plays well as a complete self-contained show).

  • Tommasi [she/her]@hexbear.netEnglish
    35·
    3 months ago

    S1 was a cool horror series and every subsequent season has been less horror and more dumb.

    The Russia plotline in particular was extremely weird and uninteresting, even ignoring the dumb political stuff like there being gulags in the 1980s.

  • Canis_latrans [comrade/them]@hexbear.netEnglish
    32·
    3 months ago

    The biggest element of fantasy in Stranger Things for modern audiences is not spider monsters or psychic powers but children having social lives unmanaged and unmediated by adults.

  • Frank [he/him, he/him]@hexbear.netEnglish
    30·
    3 months ago

    “Oh no this was all planned we had a very detailed lore bible” and then when they’re forced to hand over the lore bible to the People’s Cliffhanger Prevention Force" it’s a middle school notebook that has, like, “Spider monster - hella cool!” scribbled next to a poorly drawn cartoon of boobs.

    • TechnoUnionTypeBeat [he/him, they/them]@hexbear.netEnglish
      20·
      3 months ago

      I got burned on that shit back in the early 2000s with the Battlestar Galactica remake which, despite being fun as fuck, clearly did not have any form of planning no matter how much the creators said so

      TV production needs a fundamental overhaul. Because of the fact it’s impossible to know how long a series can go, writers either overestimate how many seasons they’ll get and end up leaving on a cliffhanger, or underestimate and pack everything into one season and then coast on fumes until cancellation. Even on the rare occasions when the creators have a specific end point and plan for it, like Supernatural, the Powers That Be at the studio always force it to go either too long or too short

    • UlyssesT [he/him]@hexbear.netEnglish
      16·
      3 months ago

      “Oh no this was all planned we had a very detailed lore bible” and then when they’re forced to hand over the lore bible to the People’s Cliffhanger Prevention Force"

      dril potential, right there.

      Whenever some “mystery box” auteur jagoff claims to have a master plan, 99% of the time it’s exactly what was in JJ Abrams’ own childhood mail-order “mystery box:” a bunch of scattered garbage and ads for more such scattered garbage.

    • vulture_god@lemmy.dbzer0.comEnglish
      10·
      3 months ago

      Good call. I gave up halfway through S3 of umbrella academy. It was just weird and goofy, the tone didn’t match S1 at all.

      • The_sleepy_woke_dialectic [he/him]@hexbear.netEnglish
        11·
        3 months ago

        They added a bunch of loose ends in the last season apparently just for the purpose of adding more loose ends to the pile, and then

        spoiler

        Literally retconned the entire show, so all the trials and character development meant nothing. Such a lazy ending.

  • hypercracker@hexbear.netEnglish
    12·
    3 months ago

    watched S2 and was like damn this is terrible and haven’t thought about the show in 8 years since (except for hearing one of the kid actors is a giant zionist or something)

  • RyanGosling [none/use name]@hexbear.netEnglish
    6·
    3 months ago

    I remember season 1 being pretty intense. When the sheriff discovers that the kid’s body in the morgue was fake after not taking anyone seriously, the kid’s mom in shambles as she tries to get him back, MKULTRA patients reliving their trauma, and everyone on edge as they deal with the monsters at the school.

    But then i see clips of the subsequent seasons and it just seems like another 80s nostalgia bait shit fuck of a show avgn

  • tombruzzo [none/use name]@hexbear.netEnglish
    4·
    3 months ago

    Season 1 has the strong hook of finding Will. I only watched season 2 after but it just lost the urgency as all the characters were back together.

    They needed something stronger to happen every season or it just turns into a melodrama. And you can’t do The Hangover and have Will disappear every season.

  • Assian_Candor [comrade/them]@hexbear.netEnglish
    3·
    3 months ago

    Eh it’s a dumb campy show. Always was.

    I actually enjoyed the mall season

    spoiler

    The soviet stuff wasnt upsetting to me since it seemed like a parody of 80s red scare panic. The meat monster and Billy redemption arc were also cool