• Amuro_eat@lemmy.blahaj.zone
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    2 days ago

    So is it Evans experiencing shame or just another narcissist action! Find out next time on “I’m actually a good person, I swear!”

  • MountingSuspicion@reddthat.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    12
    arrow-down
    6
    ·
    2 days ago

    I didn’t bother posting about it separately because there’s a lot of hostility online towards people who disagreed with the mainstream about this movie, but the movie was bad. From a technical perspective, sure it was good filmmaking, but anyone who watched the movie gets such a skewed view of what happened I think it made me dislike everyone who was involved with the direction and editing. It doesn’t surprise me at all that they left this out or said this prior to being able to confirm the specifics. They left so much out about what she did and structured the first third of the film around the idea that her trial had been just one big misunderstanding. It wasn’t. She is guilty, was found guilty, and ruined people’s lives.

    Defenders of the movie will talk about how the movie is not supposed to be a retrospective on her crimes, or how it’s supposed to make you question what you really can believe, but the framing and editing was irresponsible and showed a complete lack of respect to the people that were demonstrably hurt by her actions, and no I’m not just talking about the investors.

    • SteveGoob@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      1 day ago

      I think this is what makes the movie so interesting. Everyone comes out of the movie initially thinking that their experience with the movie was universal, but it couldn’t be farther from the truth. I’ve seen people have it make them less sympathetic, more sympathetic, change their minds entirely one from what they previously thought, or confirmed everything they already believed. Or even just entirely unsure of what to think in spite of all of the new information.

      I do think it’s interesting that you thought the movie was overly generous to her. I thought it was extremely damning. But some of the folks I saw it with felt the same as you, to the point it felt like we watched different movies. There’s something really spooky and potentially revealing about how people process the same movie so differently.

      EDIT: the whole “everyone thinks their view is universal” thing was probably more relevant on release and the few days afterward. People are probably going in with a lot more expectations and information now, and that probably changes the discourse somewhat.

      • MountingSuspicion@reddthat.com
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        20 hours ago

        I think the fact people can take such different things away is kind of a failure of the movie. Obviously not them failing at their goals, as it seems like they wanted to produce something ambiguous (see the way they filmed the two conversation options re the payment), but failing to produce what I would call a “responsible” movie.

        I think their lack of coverage of any facts of the case contributes to that. So people are making their judgements based on their interpretations of her actions solely within the film. Not to belabor the point, but considering she was found guilty by a jury of her peers, it seems kind of weird that people can walk out of a movie questioning the fairness of that outcome without actually being provided with any evidence one way or another. I don’t necessarily think it was overly generous as much as just uninformative about what actually would help your form an opinion about her guilt while pretending as though it was.

        If I made a doc about Bernie madoff and didn’t bother providing the facts of the case and just hung out with him and his family and asked him if he meant to do fraud and he said no, people I think would rightfully ask why I structured the film that way. I think a big takeaway for me was that a lot of people who saw the movie had no idea about or understanding of the case, and I think the films lack of coverage of that makes it misleading because it servers the purpose of the people that made it rather than serving honesty to the public.

    • hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      21
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      2 days ago

      the idea that her trial had been just one big misunderstanding

      That was not my impression at all. The movie just shows that Holmes and her partner think that it was a misunderstanding.

      framing and editing was irresponsible

      “responsible” reminds me of the “problematic” that people like to throw at media. It’s just too vague of a criticism imo. Like what, are people going to copy Holmes’s actions because they now think that Holmes is innocent. Just because the movie showed that Holmes thinks she is innocent? Seems like a stretch.

      • MountingSuspicion@reddthat.com
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        2 days ago

        I think the whole first third to first half of the movie is framed around the idea that Nathan is buying it. In interviews he stated he’s still not sure how he feels about it. I think the whole point of the abbot and Costello bit was to demonstrate to the audience that she “thinks differently”. You may not have been buying it, but plenty of people were and did. Even some public media critics I have respect for that were unfamiliar with her case say that they left not sure about her guilt.

        I can see how you’re relating the two terms because they can be used quite similarly here. I see them both used in a “what we owe each other” context. I think it’s irresponsible to make what is ostensibly a documentary about a criminal while not acknowledging the extent of their crimes. The fact people could leave the theater questioning her guilt makes it seem like the justice system may have failed and this poor woman was manipulated by these evil men and really just wanted to do right by people. It’s laundering her image. By making a film you’re coming from a place of authority whether you want to or not, and I think it’s “irresponsible” to use that authority in a way that could mislead people. It not just ignores but dismisses the lived experiences of the people who had their lives and careers upended in an effort to expose her personally. You can obviously disagree with that, but that’s my personal view.

        • hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          1 day ago

          The way I saw it, the movie definitely makes the entire Theranos and Holmes story more complicated, and less black and white. I think that was the point. And so, considering that the media painted Holmes as the most evil villain in the world, a nuanced take could be taken as defending her. But that’s exactly the opposite message that the movie is trying to say. Just because the movie says “it’s complicated”, does not mean “she’s innocent”. It means “it’s complicated”. But criminal trials are almosts always complicated and a verdict has to be made ar some point. Which is I think another message that the movie tries to tell.

          It not just ignores but dismisses the lived experiences of the people who had their lives and careers upended

          There were already a million documentaries about Theranos and the crimes of Holmes did. Nathan Fielder is like 8 years late to the whole story. He has to do something different. And imo if the vast majority of the coverage is about one side of a story, I don’t see the problem with one piece of media exploring the other

          • MountingSuspicion@reddthat.com
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            1 day ago

            I am not sure what you mean by “more complicated”. They showed a more personal/maternal side of her than they did in other media about her, but the movie did not cover anything at all about the facts of the case, and what it did cover was completely misleading. I think the only thing the even touched on was the “could” discussion, which is really not central to the case because of several other entirely misleading statements she made and the behavior exhibited around whistleblowers.

            For what it’s worth, I do agree that it doesn’t hurt to have media that looks at the facts from all angles, but there were no facts presented here. It followed her around with her family, cast her husband as a possible villain she’s hiding behind (which may or may not be true but is completely irrelevant to things that happened years before they met), and never actually sat her down to discuss the evidence against her. I understand that there was other media that went over the case, but plenty of people that saw the movie never saw that other media. I just think there’s a way to give her perspective and humanize her without completely ignoring the actual evidence.

            I think the my issue is that I do not understand how anyone can be familiar with the case and think that any part of the movie provided any insight in order to make the case seem more complicated. I would truly appreciate if you would be able to provide some insight into what information exactly was presented in the movie that made you feel that the case made against her was unfair.

            • hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              1 day ago

              I never said that the case made against her was unfair. But let me argue for it anyways. Afaik most of her case was about fraud, and there are two major things brought up in the movie in regards to that.

              First, fraud is inherently complicated because it requires proving intent, which is impossible to know with 100% certainty. Part of her case was about inflated and misleading claims. But the movie gives examples where statements can have multiple interpretations, like the one about how her machine “can run any test”, but what she (supposedly) really meant was that it was a platform for running tests. Most people would not interpret it that way, but if Holmes actually meant it that way, and never intended to mislead, then that would relieve her of some of the guilt (though it might still fall under “negligence”, idk I’m not a lawyer).

              The second thing the movie covered was responsibility. There were some things in her case that were definitely deceitful, like faked demos and falsified documents. But if she were coerced into falsifying them, perhaps by her partner Balwani, then that could also relieve her of some of the guilt (but again might still be “negligence”, idk).

              Lastly, let me quote wikipedia,

              The jury returned a “no verdict” on three counts of wire fraud against investor; the judge declared a mistrial on those counts because the jury failed to agree unanimously on a verdict and the government at its discretion declined to have a retrial.

              If it were a simple case, then the jury would not have struggled to come to a conclusion.

              • MountingSuspicion@reddthat.com
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                20 hours ago

                but what she (supposedly) really meant was that it was a platform for running tests

                This is part of my problem with the movie. That is not the sole statement that the fraud case hinges upon. She did and said a lot over her tenure there and it was extremely clear if you’re familiar with the facts of the case that the movie didn’t bother to include that she was purposefully misleading people. The movie certainly makes it appear as though that’s the only thing she’s said or done that could have been fraudulent and that’s simply not the case. The fact people can walk out of the movie and think that one “misunderstanding” throws the entire fraud case into question is a purposeful attempt by the film to make it seem more ambiguous than it actually is, in my opinion.

                responsibility

                If they are taking just her statements in isolation about who is responsible then yea, it’s still misleading. He was not directly involved in the business until later and there was no real attempt to prove that he did or said anything that would be considered coercive other than her vaguely gesturing that he was at fault and them framing her current partner as controlling. To my recollection they don’t ask her a single question about actions he took that might’ve made her do something she otherwise wouldn’t have. Do I think that was a healthy relationship, no, but we’re not absolved of our actions because we have an unhealthy relationship. Coercion was never even really discussed. To my recollection it was just “I trusted him” which is not an acceptable answer to why she did what she did. Here’s a relevant section from the wiki you linked:

                However, she also testified that Balwani had not forced her to make the false statements to investors, business partners, journalists and company directors that had been described in the case.

                Clearly they found her guilty of fraud. There were things they didn’t find her guilty of, sure, but if anything that goes to show there were people on the jury who were not just saying guilty because they didn’t like her personally, they were weighing the actual law regarding the charges. She was found guilty of basically the same charges she was given a no verdict for:

                Holmes was found guilty on four counts of defrauding investors: three counts of wire fraud, and one of conspiracy to commit wire fraud.

                Often times people are overcharged (which is a real problem and that should never happen), but it’s not like there were people on the jury who think she just didn’t defraud anyone.

                I’m not attempting to say the entire case is simple, but there is no question some fraud was committed if you’re aware of the facts. There may be a question of who exactly she personally defrauded, or which statements or actions specifically you’re trying to tie it to, but she knew the machines didn’t do what she was charging people to have them do. The movie doesn’t even talk about that though.

                • hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  19 hours ago

                  That is not the sole statement that the fraud case hinges upon

                  I never said it was. But those kinds of statements are what the movie focused on. To show that some of the statements were up to interpretation, and could have been interpreted in a way that was not deceitful.

                  However, she also testified that Balwani had not forced her to make the false statements to investors, business partners, journalists and company directors that had been described in the case.

                  I mean, that’s exactly what the victim in an abusive relationship would say right? “It’s all my fault, they didn’t force me to do anything wrong”. Coercion is a tricky thing to prove, just like intention, and just like fraud.

                  There were clear examples of deceit, like falsified documents, which I mentioned. But the movie was focused on the more uncertain parts of the case.

                  I’m not attempting to say the entire case is simple, but there is no question some fraud was committed if you’re aware of the facts

                  Then we agree. And I don’t think the movie is disagreeing either. The movie is simply saying that the case was not as simple as the media painted it to be.