I decided to connect with my inner 13 year old and bought Army of Darkness on Blu-Ray. Like the rest of my video collection, my goal was to rip it to my NAS so it’s available on my Kodi box; I don’t own a blu-ray player, only Blu-ray optical drives for computers. But, I decided I wanted to just pop the movie in and play it on my PC, should look pretty good on my gaming monitor.
No machine in my inventory would play it from the disc. VLC and the one or two other media players in Fedora’s pathetic excuse for a repository would play it. VLC would throw an error and tell you to look in the log for details…wherever the log is. Side note: I’m not going to see log for details if you don’t give me a link or path to that log. We hold up VLC as the best media player but it can barely play mp3 and mp4 files from the local machine, it doesn’t work across a network, it doesn’t read optical discs, it doesn’t give useful errors and I’m not looking up how to read its logs for more details.
So, several rounds of troubleshooting across a few computers later, I finally get a setup where MakeMKV will rip it from the goddamn disc. And what does the 1080p version of the movie get you? Film grain. Noisy hideous distracting film grain. Exporting it as a 720p video made it look better because crushing the resolution evened out the film grain.
Is this what liking movies is like these days? I don’t think I want to like movies anymore.
These types of post’s are great aswell. I like a mix of both Opinion, Informative, And Sharing Collection Posts. I find that the sharing post’s are less controversial. So there a great refresher. Although these types of post’s are 100% welcome along as they abide by the rules. Which you can find pinned in the community.
Like I get that the first post to the community was negative in tone and downvoted, an auspicious start, but from the perspective a media lover…
The book nerds are the loudest. Possibly because a paper book is a very visceral experience because for the several hours it takes to read a book you’re touching it the whole time. They talk about smells and sounds and feels of a thing designed only to be looked at.
After that it’s probably the audiophiles, who have spent decades arguing about vinyl versus CDs, that one is warmer or whatever. I get the appeal of vinyl, you get to fiddle with something. A turntable is an inherently mechanical thing, you get to touch it and move it. And large discs come with huge covers with lots of room for artwork and liner notes to look at and display. CDs often get a miniaturized version of this in their jewel cases.
Personally I’m not really a media quality snob; I grew up listening to 128kbps mp3 files and watching movies on VHS tapes. “The Force will be with you, Luke. Always.” was just as magical on VHS as it was in the theater on 35mm film, as it is on 1080p blu-ray. You don’t need a 4k transfer of Groundhog Day.
I’ll admit I have some nostalgia for the clacks and whirs of a tape deck or VCR, not enough to bother keeping one hooked up.
In the modern day, to a lot of us, owning physical media is a badge of at least attempting to uphold the social contract. Artists made a work of art, a movie, a TV show, a song, a book, a story, and having a legitimately purchased copy of that work rather than a pirated copy downloaded from the internet means I’m trying to pay the artist for making it so he can live. Streaming services were for a time a better way, very convenient means of legitimately accessing content instead of pirating it. Except corporate greed has almost entirely undone this; they keep altering the deal and telling us to pray they don’t alter it any further. So many are returning to physical media, which in the modern world basically means CDs for music and blu-rays for movies, 480p DVDs as a mostly obsolete fallback. And blu-rays are so riddled with paranoia that they’re difficult to actually live with. “You aren’t willing to live up to your end of the social contract under any circumstances, are you Paramount Pictures?”
That and the combination of blu-rays being very high resolution and appearing at a time when physical media is secondary to streaming, and you get lazy releases where they dumped raw video to disc without putting any effort into making it a good experience. Hence bad cropping, horrendous mismatched film grain, bad color grading, and basically nothing fitting a 16:9 screen because that’s not the aspect ratio of old TV or old movies, and you get a kind of garbage product. You get kicked in the face for trying to do right.
Honestly I couldn’t of said it better myself. You got me with the 4k Groundhog Day. I haven’t seen that in ages. Ive never been a quality snob either 🤣. The current state is honestly just saddening. Although It seems like more people are catching on to the greasy corporate crap that’s been going on though. Lets pray 🙏 that it get’s better and keep the message going. Audiophiles are probably the most extreme but interesting people that I have ever met but I respect it. They do not fuck around.