Sufficiency is a new approach to solving humanity’s consumption problems. It’s about using less, ensuring wellbeing for all humans, and staying within planetary boundaries.
I think you miss the point of history and cultural legacies.
I’m not making the argument that genocidal violence is in the genetic markup of white folks.
White folks is broadly speaking “European-descended people”.
I think this group of people is… Special in this regard. Most likely due to infighting and a long history of savagery - not due to their DNA!
So… Other peoples won’t necessarily have this brutal background, and so would not necessarily have done what white folks did.
I think owning up to the uniqueness of what it means to be white, or European-descendant, is an interesting project. And that project should not be tossed aside by some rationalisation that, incidentally, is terribly convenient for… white folks.
So it’s not about DNA yet it is about being “descended” from these people whose culture was uniquely evil? This sounds very, very like essentialism.
The convenience of the “rationalisation” is in any case moot if the person you’re addressing does not even accept your label of them (“white”). What do you propose to do about that problem? Tell them that you know what invented category they belong to better than they do?
What a mess! I resubmit my simpler solution: we are all humans, there is only one species, we are all implicated in its successes and failures, end of story.
I think you miss the point of history and cultural legacies.
I’m not making the argument that genocidal violence is in the genetic markup of white folks.
White folks is broadly speaking “European-descended people”.
I think this group of people is… Special in this regard. Most likely due to infighting and a long history of savagery - not due to their DNA!
So… Other peoples won’t necessarily have this brutal background, and so would not necessarily have done what white folks did.
I think owning up to the uniqueness of what it means to be white, or European-descendant, is an interesting project. And that project should not be tossed aside by some rationalisation that, incidentally, is terribly convenient for… white folks.
Boring meal on Christmas eve?
So it’s not about DNA yet it is about being “descended” from these people whose culture was uniquely evil? This sounds very, very like essentialism.
The convenience of the “rationalisation” is in any case moot if the person you’re addressing does not even accept your label of them (“white”). What do you propose to do about that problem? Tell them that you know what invented category they belong to better than they do?
What a mess! I resubmit my simpler solution: we are all humans, there is only one species, we are all implicated in its successes and failures, end of story.